In the picturesque town of Branford, on the scenic Thimble Islands Road, the esteemed Legacy Theatre is poised for an exhilarating showcase of talent, having unveiled an impressive repertoire of musical powerhouses for its much-anticipated Sunday Broadway concert series. This announcement follows the theater’s mid-November reveal of its vibrant 2025 mainstage lineup, a blend of classic and contemporary that promises to thrill audiences.
Opened just five years ago, the Legacy Theatre has rapidly cemented its status as a cultural cornerstone. It boasts a rich tradition that includes homegrown productions, notably its beloved adaptation of “A Christmas Carol,” which this year runs from December 4 to 15. The theater’s concert series, helmed by the illustrious John McDaniel, has become another hallmark of its programming.
The inaugural performance of the 2025 season unfurls from May 1 to 17, marking the U.S. premiere of “A Spoonful of Sherman.” This captivating revue pays homage to the legendary Disney songwriting dynasty of Robert and Richard Sherman—creators of timeless classics such as “Mary Poppins” and “The Jungle Book.” Their creative legacy is further enriched by the inclusion of Al Sherman, the Tin Pan Alley maestro, and Robbie Sherman, an acclaimed contemporary writer.
But the excitement doesn’t end there. The lineup promises to delve into the turbulent world of theatre with “Long Days,” a gripping drama by Gabe McKinley set against the backdrop of Eugene O’Neill’s monumental work, “A Long Day’s Journey Into Night,” scheduled for June 12-29. O’Neill’s connection to New London, where he spent much of his formative years, infuses this production with profound local relevance.
The season continues its bold narrative with the hauntingly immersive musical “Sweeney Todd,” crafted by the legendary Stephen Sondheim and a book by Hugh Wheeler. This gory tale of a Victorian-era barber seeking vengeance in a chillingly comedic manner features the talents of Karl Gasteyer as the notorious Sweeney and Stefanie Stiefel Williams as the equally complex Mrs. Lovett.
Rounding out the season is Michael Frayn’s “Noises Off,” a brilliant farce that offers a comedic glimpse behind the curtains of a chaotic theatre production. Expect uproarious laughter amidst the mayhem of mislaid props and errant actors vying for the limelight.
The thrill of the Sunday Broadway concert series kicks off on February 15, 2025, with the dazzling J. Harrison Ghee, whose celebrated journey includes a groundbreaking role in the musical “Some Like It Hot.” Connecticut audiences might recall Ghee’s dynamic portrayal of Lola in the national tour of “Kinky Boots,” which took the stage at the Waterbury Palace in 2016.
Following closely is Bonnie Milligan on March 2, a shining star known for her unforgettable performances in “Head Over Heels” and “Kimberly Akimbo,” the latter earning her a Tony Award.
The concert series continues on March 30 with Norbert Leo Butz, a two-time Tony awardee revered for his roles in “Dirty Rotten Scoundrels” and “Catch Me If You Can,” who made waves with his recent portrayal of Bill Belichick in the much-discussed series, “American Sports Story: Aaron Hernandez.”
April welcomes Euan Morton, renowned for representing Boy George in “Taboo,” while July 13 will see Broadway veteran Nicholas Rodriguez grace the stage. Later, the iconic Donna McKechnie, immortalized for her role as Cassie in “A Chorus Line,” delights audiences on September 7.
Finally, the series culminates on October 26 with the extraordinary Karen Mason, frequently celebrated for her roles in “Hairspray” and “Mamma Mia,” bringing her storied experience to this dynamic concert series.
This curated concert series, artfully orchestrated by the seasoned McDaniel—whose illustrious career includes leading the band on Rosie O’Donnell’s talk show and conducting for legends like Carol Burnett—marks a significant moment in Connecticut’s cultural scene. As local cabaret performances flourish, the Legacy Theatre stands at the forefront, thanks to its intimate setting and McDaniel’s artistic vision.
Subscription options for the Legacy Theatre’s enriching offerings can be explored at their official site, with single tickets becoming available in January, promising a season replete with entertainment and unforgettable memories.
